Whether Kenneth Lay and Jeff Skilling still believe they were gutsy entrepreneurs, not greedy fraudsters, is immaterial. For now, the guilty verdicts the two Enron bosses received from a jury that deliberated for six days overshadow everything else. National Public Radio analyst Daniel Schorr spoke for many when he said he didn’t expect to see this kind of humbling of corporate America in his lifetime.
Lay was found guilty by the jury of six counts of conspiracy and fraud and Skilling on 18 counts but was acquitted on all but one charge of insider trading. In a separate trial in front of the judge Lay was also found guilty of bank fraud. He faces a maximum of 45 years in jail (plus up to 120 years for the bank fraud) and Skilling could receive 185 years inside. The judge is set to sentence them September 11. Both men said that they would mount an appeal.
From the outset, investors and employees had no doubt who was to blame for Enron’s collapse. Until Lay and Skilling stood in court, no top Enron executive had faced trial for -- much less been convicted of -- any wrongdoing. Some 30 people were charged in connection with the case. Nearly half made a deal and some testified for the government.
This led both defendants to put too much faith in weakness of such evidence.
Skilling and Lay sought to portray Enron as a fundamentally sound company that had been brought down by panic in the markets brought on by short-sellers and stoked by the media. The jurors saw little evidence that subordinates could have conducted massive fraud without the chief executive’s knowledge.
The defendants’ contention that they had merely engaged in activities common during the tech boom was puerile. An Enron-scale juggling of accounts was not so widespread as to rise to the level of standard operating procedure. In sum, the defense’s attempt to portray Enron’s collapse as an intrinsic hazard of capitalism was doomed from the start.
Are we on the threshold of the Age of Corporate Integrity? Businessmen may have self-interest in bemoaning the Sarbanes-Oxley legislation on corporate governance as excessive. The suspected malfeasance of a few cannot justify unreasonable encumbrances across the boardrooms. Moreover, how long would it take for such restrictions to impose a chilling effect on America’s entrepreneurial zeal?
Yet the onus is on corporate America. It could do itself – and the rest of us -- a huge favor by resisting the temptation to describe out-and-out crime as risk-taking.
Saturday, May 27, 2006
Tuesday, May 23, 2006
Who Is Bin Laden Really Trying To Exonerate?
The irrationality of the Zacarias Moussaoui saga finally seems to have gotten to his boss. Well, make that his purported boss. An audio recording on an Islamist website supposedly of Al Qaeda chief Osama bin Laden denies Moussaoui, the only person convicted over the 9/11 attacks, was involved in the operation.
Moussaoui, a French citizen of Moroccan descent, pleaded guilty in April 2005 to
six charges of conspiracy over the hijacking attacks on New York and Washington.
When a U.S. court jailed him for life without parole for his role in the attacks earlier this month, it only left room for endless speculation.
From the outset, the prosecution had called for the death penalty, arguing that “there is no place on this good Earth” for him. The defense recommended “the long slow death of a common criminal” in prison, rather than martyrdom through execution.
And Moussaoui himself? At first, he protested vigorously that he had nothing to do with, and knew nothing about, the 9/11 attacks. Then suddenly he claimed to be a central figure in the plot. He had planned, he claimed, to fly a fifth suicide mission into the White House that day, and would certainly have done so had he not already been behind bars, arrested four weeks earlier on a minor immigration charge. His alleged co-hijacker, Richard Reid, the “shoe bomber” U.S. officials arrested after the 9/11 attacks, laughed off that story.
During the final six weeks of hearings, Moussaoui virtually lusted for the death penalty. He let it be known that he had “no regret, no remorse.” In fact, he wished that it could be September 11th every day.
Then he seemed to recognize that life imprisonment would be “a greater punishment than being sentenced to death.” When the jury at last handed down its verdict on May 3, he still could not help crying out defiantly: “America, you lost!”
In closed session with trial lawyers, Leonie Brinkema, the presiding judge, said she herself did not believe Moussaoui’s claim that he knew details of the plot in advance.
Was Moussaoui a star player or just a paranoid schizophrenic with grand delusions with perhaps no knowledge of the main plot? The word of Jihad Inc. CEO should have been the last. “I am the one in charge of the 19 brothers and I never assigned brother Zacarias to be with them in that mission," the purported voice of Bin Laden says. The man in the recording also said that none of the Guantanamo Bay detainees were connected to the attacks.
Delve deeper and the argument on the tape gets a bit tenuous. “Since Zacarias Moussaoui was still learning how to fly, he wasn't No 20 in the group, as your government claimed,” the man said to be Bin Laden says. Moussaoui confessed because of pressure caused by over four years in prison, the tape went on.
But wasn’t Moussaoui arrested a month before the attacks. Had he continued, he might as well have completed that training and become the 20th hijacker. So what was the purpose of the latest tape? Did the man purporting to be Bin Laden want to exonerate Moussaoui or exonerate himself for having chosen someone who bungled it all the way to the end?
Moussaoui, a French citizen of Moroccan descent, pleaded guilty in April 2005 to
six charges of conspiracy over the hijacking attacks on New York and Washington.
When a U.S. court jailed him for life without parole for his role in the attacks earlier this month, it only left room for endless speculation.
From the outset, the prosecution had called for the death penalty, arguing that “there is no place on this good Earth” for him. The defense recommended “the long slow death of a common criminal” in prison, rather than martyrdom through execution.
And Moussaoui himself? At first, he protested vigorously that he had nothing to do with, and knew nothing about, the 9/11 attacks. Then suddenly he claimed to be a central figure in the plot. He had planned, he claimed, to fly a fifth suicide mission into the White House that day, and would certainly have done so had he not already been behind bars, arrested four weeks earlier on a minor immigration charge. His alleged co-hijacker, Richard Reid, the “shoe bomber” U.S. officials arrested after the 9/11 attacks, laughed off that story.
During the final six weeks of hearings, Moussaoui virtually lusted for the death penalty. He let it be known that he had “no regret, no remorse.” In fact, he wished that it could be September 11th every day.
Then he seemed to recognize that life imprisonment would be “a greater punishment than being sentenced to death.” When the jury at last handed down its verdict on May 3, he still could not help crying out defiantly: “America, you lost!”
In closed session with trial lawyers, Leonie Brinkema, the presiding judge, said she herself did not believe Moussaoui’s claim that he knew details of the plot in advance.
Was Moussaoui a star player or just a paranoid schizophrenic with grand delusions with perhaps no knowledge of the main plot? The word of Jihad Inc. CEO should have been the last. “I am the one in charge of the 19 brothers and I never assigned brother Zacarias to be with them in that mission," the purported voice of Bin Laden says. The man in the recording also said that none of the Guantanamo Bay detainees were connected to the attacks.
Delve deeper and the argument on the tape gets a bit tenuous. “Since Zacarias Moussaoui was still learning how to fly, he wasn't No 20 in the group, as your government claimed,” the man said to be Bin Laden says. Moussaoui confessed because of pressure caused by over four years in prison, the tape went on.
But wasn’t Moussaoui arrested a month before the attacks. Had he continued, he might as well have completed that training and become the 20th hijacker. So what was the purpose of the latest tape? Did the man purporting to be Bin Laden want to exonerate Moussaoui or exonerate himself for having chosen someone who bungled it all the way to the end?
Friday, May 19, 2006
From Afar, Cultural Revolution Still Haunts China
As China tries to exorcise the ghosts of its traumatic past, some of the shadows just refuse to disappear. The 40th anniversary of the Great Proletariat Cultural Revolution hasn’t spurred the Asian giant into paroxysms of patriotic fervor. Today’s Chinese communist leaders consider the Great Helmsman 70 percent correct. As one of the darkest decades of its past, the Cultural Revolution falls in the 30 percent of Mao’s transgressions.
Stripped of its ideological sheen, the Cultural Revolution was essentially Mao’s effort to strengthen his grip on the party and the country. Amid the omnipresence of Mao’s multi-sized portraits, and the teeming millions swearing fealty each day, state atheism only masked another fervid religiosity.
Some supporters – dwindling in numbers but less so in conviction – still insist that the Cultural Revolution played a crucial role in unifying the vast and largely ungovernable country that Long Marchers took over. They are right. But at what price?
Mao unleashed an orgy of madness to eliminate political rivals and perpetuate cult following. The more insidious effects continue to be experienced in the murders of hundreds of thousands of innocent and ordinary people and the maiming, torture and displacement of countless millions others.
It must be truly difficult for post-Mao Chinese from Shenzen to Shanghai to believe that the state actually equated education with counterrevolution. The wave of ideological purification didn’t spare Deng Xiaoping, the architect of China’s spectacular economic miracle, whom Mao branded a capitalist-roader and purged twice. Writers, artists, teachers, journalists and freethinkers were germs society needed to immunize itself against at all costs.
Even the fiercest critics of the Chinese communist leadership concede that the country’s economic transformation would inevitably bring political change. Deng’s Four Modernizations stand as a tacit repudiation of the Cultural Revolution, although the Tiananmen Square massacre under his watch raised the specter of regression. An official Chinese repudiation is perhaps too much to expect from a leadership that still cherishes 70 percent of what Mao represented.
But the Great Helmsman continues to cast a long and troubling shadow on China from next door. The tiny Himalayan kingdom of Nepal, sandwiched between Tibet and India, has all but fallen to Maoist insurgents. By tactically allying themselves with the mainstream political parties – most of them communist – the Maoists led street protests that forced King Gyanendra last month to relinquish political powers he had seized 15 months ago.
The Maoists and the mainstream parties, now in power, are preparing for a constitutional assembly that they hope would, among other things, abolish the 238-year monarchy. With the king out of the way, the Maoists are almost certain to turn their guns on the democratic parties.
What inspires the Nepalese rebels is not China, but Nepal’s southern neighbor India, where Maoist groups are active in at least 13 of 28 states. A Maoist victory in Nepal would be a seminal event in the creation of what extreme left-wing groups in South Asia call a compact revolutionary zone. From the Philippines to Peru, Maoist groups impatient to unleash the next wave of revolution.
The growing vulnerability of India -- China’s principal Asian rival -- to Maoism should have been the least of Beijing’s worries. But the Chinese leadership is alarmed. Beijing refuses to call the Nepalese rebels Maoists, saying their violent methods gives a bad name to their departed leader. The Chinese prefer the term anti-government guerrillas – and all the disapproval it connotes. The Nepalese Maoists, for their part, denounce the Chinese communists as deviants.
The Chinese leadership recognizes the growing rural-urban economic and social divide in their own country could breed some nostalgia for the days when everyone was poor but equally so. If Maoism could still be relevant in the neighborhood, why shouldn’t it be so at home?
Stripped of its ideological sheen, the Cultural Revolution was essentially Mao’s effort to strengthen his grip on the party and the country. Amid the omnipresence of Mao’s multi-sized portraits, and the teeming millions swearing fealty each day, state atheism only masked another fervid religiosity.
Some supporters – dwindling in numbers but less so in conviction – still insist that the Cultural Revolution played a crucial role in unifying the vast and largely ungovernable country that Long Marchers took over. They are right. But at what price?
Mao unleashed an orgy of madness to eliminate political rivals and perpetuate cult following. The more insidious effects continue to be experienced in the murders of hundreds of thousands of innocent and ordinary people and the maiming, torture and displacement of countless millions others.
It must be truly difficult for post-Mao Chinese from Shenzen to Shanghai to believe that the state actually equated education with counterrevolution. The wave of ideological purification didn’t spare Deng Xiaoping, the architect of China’s spectacular economic miracle, whom Mao branded a capitalist-roader and purged twice. Writers, artists, teachers, journalists and freethinkers were germs society needed to immunize itself against at all costs.
Even the fiercest critics of the Chinese communist leadership concede that the country’s economic transformation would inevitably bring political change. Deng’s Four Modernizations stand as a tacit repudiation of the Cultural Revolution, although the Tiananmen Square massacre under his watch raised the specter of regression. An official Chinese repudiation is perhaps too much to expect from a leadership that still cherishes 70 percent of what Mao represented.
But the Great Helmsman continues to cast a long and troubling shadow on China from next door. The tiny Himalayan kingdom of Nepal, sandwiched between Tibet and India, has all but fallen to Maoist insurgents. By tactically allying themselves with the mainstream political parties – most of them communist – the Maoists led street protests that forced King Gyanendra last month to relinquish political powers he had seized 15 months ago.
The Maoists and the mainstream parties, now in power, are preparing for a constitutional assembly that they hope would, among other things, abolish the 238-year monarchy. With the king out of the way, the Maoists are almost certain to turn their guns on the democratic parties.
What inspires the Nepalese rebels is not China, but Nepal’s southern neighbor India, where Maoist groups are active in at least 13 of 28 states. A Maoist victory in Nepal would be a seminal event in the creation of what extreme left-wing groups in South Asia call a compact revolutionary zone. From the Philippines to Peru, Maoist groups impatient to unleash the next wave of revolution.
The growing vulnerability of India -- China’s principal Asian rival -- to Maoism should have been the least of Beijing’s worries. But the Chinese leadership is alarmed. Beijing refuses to call the Nepalese rebels Maoists, saying their violent methods gives a bad name to their departed leader. The Chinese prefer the term anti-government guerrillas – and all the disapproval it connotes. The Nepalese Maoists, for their part, denounce the Chinese communists as deviants.
The Chinese leadership recognizes the growing rural-urban economic and social divide in their own country could breed some nostalgia for the days when everyone was poor but equally so. If Maoism could still be relevant in the neighborhood, why shouldn’t it be so at home?
Monday, May 15, 2006
From Justice To Homeland Security And Back?
Hearing President George W. Bush frame the debate on national TV, immigration has a chance of returning to its pre-9/11 abode within the trinity of equality, justice and opportunity.
The incorporation of the former Immigration and Naturalization Service into the Department of Homeland Security had signaled the transformation of one of America’s founding tenets into the imperative of national security.
The legal-illegal dimensions of the immigration debate obscured the core issue: how to ensure the overall enrichment of American values, society, power and accomplishments without imperiling the nation’s security, supremacy of rule of law and overburdened public services.
With passions running high on both sides of the debate, participants found themselves caught in a chicken-or-egg debate. Tighter border security before the regularization of undocumented aliens or vice versa? President Bush began his speech with the imperative of boosting border patrol personnel and technology before transitioning to the issue of undocumented aliens already in the United States. In retrospect, Bush’s speech was more of a thematic tapestry than an aggregation of political, economic, cultural and national security brushstrokes.
Doubtless, the House’s restrictive immigration bill and the Senate’s attempts to offer a more humane approach are rooted in their divergent institutional structures and electoral imperatives.
As the person responsible for signing into law a reconciled version of the two approaches as well as for the ultimate judgment of the American people, President Bush certainly felt he had to go on prime-time TV to press the case for action.
In acknowledging the complexities of the issue, the president alerted the country to the real and lasting consequences of playing on fears. In showing the compassionate side of America, Bush was equally vigorous in his defense of the supremacy of the rule of law. In essence, people who have paid their debts to society for breaking the law can have a second chance.
The real value of Bush’s intervention was less in the articulation of the philosophical dimensions of the immigration debate than in the forceful advocacy of the urgency of a comprehensive solution to a complex problem.
Immigration may never return to the jurisdiction of the Department of Justice. Americans are certainly capable of doing justice to one of their core founding principles through their collective conscience.
The incorporation of the former Immigration and Naturalization Service into the Department of Homeland Security had signaled the transformation of one of America’s founding tenets into the imperative of national security.
The legal-illegal dimensions of the immigration debate obscured the core issue: how to ensure the overall enrichment of American values, society, power and accomplishments without imperiling the nation’s security, supremacy of rule of law and overburdened public services.
With passions running high on both sides of the debate, participants found themselves caught in a chicken-or-egg debate. Tighter border security before the regularization of undocumented aliens or vice versa? President Bush began his speech with the imperative of boosting border patrol personnel and technology before transitioning to the issue of undocumented aliens already in the United States. In retrospect, Bush’s speech was more of a thematic tapestry than an aggregation of political, economic, cultural and national security brushstrokes.
Doubtless, the House’s restrictive immigration bill and the Senate’s attempts to offer a more humane approach are rooted in their divergent institutional structures and electoral imperatives.
As the person responsible for signing into law a reconciled version of the two approaches as well as for the ultimate judgment of the American people, President Bush certainly felt he had to go on prime-time TV to press the case for action.
In acknowledging the complexities of the issue, the president alerted the country to the real and lasting consequences of playing on fears. In showing the compassionate side of America, Bush was equally vigorous in his defense of the supremacy of the rule of law. In essence, people who have paid their debts to society for breaking the law can have a second chance.
The real value of Bush’s intervention was less in the articulation of the philosophical dimensions of the immigration debate than in the forceful advocacy of the urgency of a comprehensive solution to a complex problem.
Immigration may never return to the jurisdiction of the Department of Justice. Americans are certainly capable of doing justice to one of their core founding principles through their collective conscience.
Sunday, May 14, 2006
Thatcher’s Long Shadow On Labour
Confronted with growing calls from within his Labour party for a timetable for his departure, British Prime Minister Tony Blair has a standard response: Although he does not intend to go on and on forever, he cannot and will not offer a deadline because that would paralyze the government and the party.
Over the last 10 days, the latter half of the embattled premier’s argument has sounded increasingly redundant. In the aftermath of Labour's defeat in the May 4 local elections and the cabinet reshuffle that followed, the punditocracy agrees that Blair has lost control of his party.
Plummeting popularity ratings and embittered colleagues are a disastrous recipe in the best of times. With his political authority in tatters, the prospect of Blair serving a full third term as prime minister is fast receding. It is only a matter of time before Gordon Brown, the chancellor of the exchequer and Blair’s heir apparent, is elevated to the top job.
What is less certain – and more germane to Labour’s longevity in power – is the manner in which the transition is completed. In the aftermath of the Iraq invasion, when Blair’s downhill slide accelerated, factional infighting was a luxury Labour could afford. With the Tories in almost perpetual disarray and the Liberal Democrats struggling to expand their base, Labour leaders knew voters had no alternative to putting up with an accumulation of scandals and double dealing in the ruling party.
The Tories have heightened the urgency for Labour to close ranks not just because of their remarkable gains in the local elections. The bad blood left by the dethronement of Margaret Thatcher in 1990 emaciated the Conservatives for a decade. Tory leader David Cameron is yet to prove he can lead his party back to power. But that prospect can only grow with a deepening of the succession struggle in Labour.
A transition plan should not be that difficult to work out. In exchange for an explicit commitment to step down -- most pundits believe some time next year would be propitious -- Blair could demand Brown’s full support for the remainder of his agenda.
Pensions, nuclear energy, health and education are but a few areas that need Blair’s undivided attention if the premier is to leave behind a lasting legacy.
Blair’s success there would strengthen Brown’s ability to implement the party agenda and to lead a united Labour to another electoral victory.
Over the last 10 days, the latter half of the embattled premier’s argument has sounded increasingly redundant. In the aftermath of Labour's defeat in the May 4 local elections and the cabinet reshuffle that followed, the punditocracy agrees that Blair has lost control of his party.
Plummeting popularity ratings and embittered colleagues are a disastrous recipe in the best of times. With his political authority in tatters, the prospect of Blair serving a full third term as prime minister is fast receding. It is only a matter of time before Gordon Brown, the chancellor of the exchequer and Blair’s heir apparent, is elevated to the top job.
What is less certain – and more germane to Labour’s longevity in power – is the manner in which the transition is completed. In the aftermath of the Iraq invasion, when Blair’s downhill slide accelerated, factional infighting was a luxury Labour could afford. With the Tories in almost perpetual disarray and the Liberal Democrats struggling to expand their base, Labour leaders knew voters had no alternative to putting up with an accumulation of scandals and double dealing in the ruling party.
The Tories have heightened the urgency for Labour to close ranks not just because of their remarkable gains in the local elections. The bad blood left by the dethronement of Margaret Thatcher in 1990 emaciated the Conservatives for a decade. Tory leader David Cameron is yet to prove he can lead his party back to power. But that prospect can only grow with a deepening of the succession struggle in Labour.
A transition plan should not be that difficult to work out. In exchange for an explicit commitment to step down -- most pundits believe some time next year would be propitious -- Blair could demand Brown’s full support for the remainder of his agenda.
Pensions, nuclear energy, health and education are but a few areas that need Blair’s undivided attention if the premier is to leave behind a lasting legacy.
Blair’s success there would strengthen Brown’s ability to implement the party agenda and to lead a united Labour to another electoral victory.
Friday, May 12, 2006
Has Privacy Lost Some Of Its Sanctity?
By now most Americans have probably figured out the real story in the latest revelations of the Bush administration’s domestic spying. Most Americans don’t seem to mind, according to a Washington Post-ABC News poll.
USA Today’s disclosure that the National Security Agency, after Sept. 11, 2001, began assembling a database of records of domestic calls has worked up Congress the most.
Senator Patrick Leahy (D-Vermont) held up a copy of the newspaper to shame everyone in the chamber and beyond. As the ranking Democrat on the Judiciary Committee, Sen. Leahy couldn’t have squandered such an opening at a time when his party is getting luckier by the week in the run-up to the November elections.
The conservative universe, on the other hand, is pulsating with anxiety over the possibility of both housing falling to the Dems. In that case, Sen. Leahy would become chairman of the Senate committee most closely involved with the impeachment of Bush so many Democrats are counting on.
For many Republicans, the prospect of a loss in November might have been bearable if the Harry Reids, Nancy Pelosis and Howard Deans had earned victory on other own. It’s President George W. Bush’s brazen flaunting of his lameduck-ness that’s troubling. If, anything, the latest revelations have stiffened the Bush administration’s resolve in pushing the nomination of Gen. Michael Hayden, the former chief of the NSA, as the new director of the Central Intelligence Agency.
Now don’t get me wrong. The issues here are serious. The NSA, according to USA Today, attempted to keep track of all phone calls made in the United States and use them in an elaborate data-mining operation. The agency did not go to any court for approval. Rather, it simply asked several major telecommunications companies to turn over huge volumes of call data. Only one refused.
President Bush and the telephone companies insist their actions were strictly in accordance with the law. Doubtless, the ambiguity of the law permits such straight-in-the-eye assertions. How else could these companies have provided the feds with records on over a trillion calls without breaching privacy laws?
The implication that the United States has such a surfeit of al-Qaeda suspects is certainly amusing. But it is no laughing matter to our elected representatives. The absence of public debate and judicial review in the whole process is less troubling than the enormous scope for abuse of the process. Where’s the public outrage?
It doesn’t exist, according to the Washington Post-ABC News poll. Some 66 percent of Americans said they would not be bothered if NSA collected records of personal calls they had made, the poll found. Maybe public expectations of privacy have undergone a major shift in this age of terrorism.
Or is it technology? With so many people blabbering into their cell-phones on sidewalks, hospitals, restaurants – and yes – public libraries with such abandon, can we conclude that privacy has lost its traditional sanctity?
Culture, too, has played a part. People have learned to live with data-mining. After all, telemarketers, credit-card companies and email spammers seem to know our preferences almost as well as we do. With everything revolving around your social security number, there’s little telling who’s watching which planet for what purpose.
So what’s the big deal if the government is invading a space Corporate America has long trespassed on? Especially when there hasn’t been another 9/11?
USA Today’s disclosure that the National Security Agency, after Sept. 11, 2001, began assembling a database of records of domestic calls has worked up Congress the most.
Senator Patrick Leahy (D-Vermont) held up a copy of the newspaper to shame everyone in the chamber and beyond. As the ranking Democrat on the Judiciary Committee, Sen. Leahy couldn’t have squandered such an opening at a time when his party is getting luckier by the week in the run-up to the November elections.
The conservative universe, on the other hand, is pulsating with anxiety over the possibility of both housing falling to the Dems. In that case, Sen. Leahy would become chairman of the Senate committee most closely involved with the impeachment of Bush so many Democrats are counting on.
For many Republicans, the prospect of a loss in November might have been bearable if the Harry Reids, Nancy Pelosis and Howard Deans had earned victory on other own. It’s President George W. Bush’s brazen flaunting of his lameduck-ness that’s troubling. If, anything, the latest revelations have stiffened the Bush administration’s resolve in pushing the nomination of Gen. Michael Hayden, the former chief of the NSA, as the new director of the Central Intelligence Agency.
Now don’t get me wrong. The issues here are serious. The NSA, according to USA Today, attempted to keep track of all phone calls made in the United States and use them in an elaborate data-mining operation. The agency did not go to any court for approval. Rather, it simply asked several major telecommunications companies to turn over huge volumes of call data. Only one refused.
President Bush and the telephone companies insist their actions were strictly in accordance with the law. Doubtless, the ambiguity of the law permits such straight-in-the-eye assertions. How else could these companies have provided the feds with records on over a trillion calls without breaching privacy laws?
The implication that the United States has such a surfeit of al-Qaeda suspects is certainly amusing. But it is no laughing matter to our elected representatives. The absence of public debate and judicial review in the whole process is less troubling than the enormous scope for abuse of the process. Where’s the public outrage?
It doesn’t exist, according to the Washington Post-ABC News poll. Some 66 percent of Americans said they would not be bothered if NSA collected records of personal calls they had made, the poll found. Maybe public expectations of privacy have undergone a major shift in this age of terrorism.
Or is it technology? With so many people blabbering into their cell-phones on sidewalks, hospitals, restaurants – and yes – public libraries with such abandon, can we conclude that privacy has lost its traditional sanctity?
Culture, too, has played a part. People have learned to live with data-mining. After all, telemarketers, credit-card companies and email spammers seem to know our preferences almost as well as we do. With everything revolving around your social security number, there’s little telling who’s watching which planet for what purpose.
So what’s the big deal if the government is invading a space Corporate America has long trespassed on? Especially when there hasn’t been another 9/11?
Thursday, May 11, 2006
Thailand’s Real Democracy Test
Now that Thailand’s constitutional court has annulled last month's controversial parliamentary elections and ordered a new vote, it is tempting to believe the kingdom’s constitutional crisis has blown over. In fact, the country, which has been under absolute monarchy or military rule for much of its life, may face a more crucial test of its democratic resilience.
The April 2 election was doomed when it failed to return a full 500-member lower house. Some 10 million of the 28 million voters heeded the opposition and marked the “no vote” box on their ballot papers. As a result, scores of candidates from the ruling Thai Rak Thai party failed to win at least a fifth of votes cast required to validate the outcome. This flaw left Thailand without a parliament and with a caretaker government for over a month. Hundreds of lawsuits were filed by opposition parties, protest groups and academics. Many accused the Election Commission of bias and inefficiency.
Admittedly, this was an election Thais could have avoided. Thaksin decided to return to the people only a year after being re-elected prime minister in a sweeping victory. But he could hardly be blamed. The kingdom’s constitutional crisis really began when Thaksin’s opponents refused to defer to that mandate.
During months of street protests in the capital, demonstrators accused the premier of corruption and demanded his resignation. Thaksin, for his part, rebuffed what he considered an elitist display of people power in the capital. He chose to fortify his flank with Thais in the countryside, who have benefited from his cheap health care and rural development policies. However, the indecisive outcome, the prospect of more protests and an audience with King Bhumibol prompted him to step down.
The situation could still have been salvaged. The Election Commission conducted another round of voting to fill the remaining seats, but failed. A third round was being planned when King Bhumibol went on national TV to urge Thailand’s judges to find a solution. Otherwise, the monarch warned, the country might “sink more than 4,000 meters under the sea.” Those words from the widely revered monarch had the effect of a political tsunami.
The court cited the Election Commission’s extraordinary haste in organizing the election without giving sufficient time to smaller parties and candidates to prepare themselves. Specifically, the judges interpreted the constitution as requiring a poll to be held at least 45 days after the dissolution of parliament; the April 2 elections were held only 37 days later. Furthermore, in the court’s opinion, the secrecy of balloting was compromised by changes to the positioning of polling-booths, which made it possible to peer over voters’ shoulders.
Although Thaksin’s gamble failed, he is not about to walk into the twilight as his adversaries would like. He was wise to recognize that his resignation would help to defuse the crisis. However, if Thaksin wants to vindicate himself by seeking his old job, he has every right. Contrary to the assertions of Thaksin’s critics, the constitutional crisis did not stem solely from a self-centered politician’s infinite arrogance and greed for power. The opposition’s refusal to play by the rules did no less harm.
The April 2 election was doomed when it failed to return a full 500-member lower house. Some 10 million of the 28 million voters heeded the opposition and marked the “no vote” box on their ballot papers. As a result, scores of candidates from the ruling Thai Rak Thai party failed to win at least a fifth of votes cast required to validate the outcome. This flaw left Thailand without a parliament and with a caretaker government for over a month. Hundreds of lawsuits were filed by opposition parties, protest groups and academics. Many accused the Election Commission of bias and inefficiency.
Admittedly, this was an election Thais could have avoided. Thaksin decided to return to the people only a year after being re-elected prime minister in a sweeping victory. But he could hardly be blamed. The kingdom’s constitutional crisis really began when Thaksin’s opponents refused to defer to that mandate.
During months of street protests in the capital, demonstrators accused the premier of corruption and demanded his resignation. Thaksin, for his part, rebuffed what he considered an elitist display of people power in the capital. He chose to fortify his flank with Thais in the countryside, who have benefited from his cheap health care and rural development policies. However, the indecisive outcome, the prospect of more protests and an audience with King Bhumibol prompted him to step down.
The situation could still have been salvaged. The Election Commission conducted another round of voting to fill the remaining seats, but failed. A third round was being planned when King Bhumibol went on national TV to urge Thailand’s judges to find a solution. Otherwise, the monarch warned, the country might “sink more than 4,000 meters under the sea.” Those words from the widely revered monarch had the effect of a political tsunami.
The court cited the Election Commission’s extraordinary haste in organizing the election without giving sufficient time to smaller parties and candidates to prepare themselves. Specifically, the judges interpreted the constitution as requiring a poll to be held at least 45 days after the dissolution of parliament; the April 2 elections were held only 37 days later. Furthermore, in the court’s opinion, the secrecy of balloting was compromised by changes to the positioning of polling-booths, which made it possible to peer over voters’ shoulders.
Although Thaksin’s gamble failed, he is not about to walk into the twilight as his adversaries would like. He was wise to recognize that his resignation would help to defuse the crisis. However, if Thaksin wants to vindicate himself by seeking his old job, he has every right. Contrary to the assertions of Thaksin’s critics, the constitutional crisis did not stem solely from a self-centered politician’s infinite arrogance and greed for power. The opposition’s refusal to play by the rules did no less harm.
Friday, May 05, 2006
France’s Watergate And America’s Right
During the run-up to the 2003 invasion of Iraq, Dominique de Villepin became the face of French self-righteousness for many American conservatives. Of course, we now know France was nowhere close to any principle of multilateralism when it sought to delay and eventually block United Nations authorization of the invasion.
The oil concessions Saddam Hussein promised Paris in exchange for saving his regime were worth a dozen more Security Council vetoes.
In hindsight, many American conservatives probably wish France had succeeded in stopping the American-British steamroller. Even to them, De Villepin’s holier-than-thou countenance is still too much to take.
As America and Britain confronted the real consequences of unseating an entrenched autocrat, De Villepin stepped up the ladder to become prime minister. His climb-down earlier this year from an ambitious youth employment reforms seemed enough to doom his presidential prospects. The scandal uncovered this week threatens to end De Villepin’s political career.
The French prime minister is accused of ordering a secret investigation of his own Interior Minister Nicolas Sarkozy to examine if he received any kickbacks from the $2.8 billion sale of French frigates to Taiwan in 1991.
Sarkozy, of course, is a potential De Villepin rival in the race to succeed Jacques Chirac as president. Supporters of the prime minister will continue to emphasize that he is not personally accused of any wrong doing or corruption. So there is no reason for his resignation.
Sarkozy allies, on the other hand, will have a field day mocking a premier who lacks the guts to look straight in the face of his minister and ask whether he took any money.
As the French grapple with these and other questions, American conservatives can savor their own moment of irony in what is being called France’s Watergate.
The oil concessions Saddam Hussein promised Paris in exchange for saving his regime were worth a dozen more Security Council vetoes.
In hindsight, many American conservatives probably wish France had succeeded in stopping the American-British steamroller. Even to them, De Villepin’s holier-than-thou countenance is still too much to take.
As America and Britain confronted the real consequences of unseating an entrenched autocrat, De Villepin stepped up the ladder to become prime minister. His climb-down earlier this year from an ambitious youth employment reforms seemed enough to doom his presidential prospects. The scandal uncovered this week threatens to end De Villepin’s political career.
The French prime minister is accused of ordering a secret investigation of his own Interior Minister Nicolas Sarkozy to examine if he received any kickbacks from the $2.8 billion sale of French frigates to Taiwan in 1991.
Sarkozy, of course, is a potential De Villepin rival in the race to succeed Jacques Chirac as president. Supporters of the prime minister will continue to emphasize that he is not personally accused of any wrong doing or corruption. So there is no reason for his resignation.
Sarkozy allies, on the other hand, will have a field day mocking a premier who lacks the guts to look straight in the face of his minister and ask whether he took any money.
As the French grapple with these and other questions, American conservatives can savor their own moment of irony in what is being called France’s Watergate.
Thursday, May 04, 2006
Chavez, Morales And Bolivar Revolution
Has Hugo Chavez’s imperial presidency finally started building that grand empire for the world’s left? When Bolivian President Evo Morales, following through on a campaign promise, nationalized his country’s oil and natural gas industries this week, the Venezuelan leader’s fingerprints were all over the place.
Morales stunned critics and supporters not by what he did but by the way he did it. Instead of going the legislative route -- which even the most unreconstructed ex-commie cannot avoid paying lip service to – Morales issued a decree befitting Stalin. And that, too, on May Day – the day of the year that fires up the international left to resurrect what much of the world has discarded as a losing cause.
To make himself understood, Morales dispatched the armed forces to secure the oil facilities. That’s the kind of radical overhaul Chavez’s revolution envisaged from its inception seven years ago. Venezuela’s state oil firm PDVSA, after all, is advising the Morales government. Chavez visited Morales to support his actions.
Bolivia is not outright expelling foreign companies in the Salvador Allende tradition. Instead, foreign firms will have to sign new contracts within the next 180 days and agree to channel all their sales through the Bolivian state. If they decline, then they would have to leave the country. In most cases, they will have to hand over 82 percent of production to the state.
The Chavez route has won other adherents, which must be worrying to his critics. Ecuador recently approved a law that allows the government to renegotiate contracts with oil companies. Peru’s presidential candidate Ollanta Humala has promised to nationalize gas reserves and production if he wins the runoff election. At the wider trade level, Bolivia, Venezuela and Cuba recently signed the Peoples' Trade Agreement, ostensibly their answer to the Free Trade Area of the Americas. Latin America’s left, however, is not solidly behind Chavez. Brazil, Chile and Uruguay have leftist governments, but they have not pursued nationalization policies.
Can Morales sustain his policy? Bolivia may have South America's second-largest reserves of natural gas, but its oil industry remains underdeveloped. Unlike Venezuela, Bolivia does not have steady oil revenues to fuel further economic growth.
The poorest country in South America, Bolivia is dependent on foreign investment and expertise to extract and export its huge gas reserves.
Morales is the first person who recognizes that energy revenues are nowhere near boosting social and infrastructure spending and securing the country’s long-term debt sustainability.
The best Bolivia can hope for is tighter conditions for foreign firms. So why has Morales exhibited such boldness? Could it have to do with the fact that Chavez calls his cause the Bolivar Revolution?
Morales stunned critics and supporters not by what he did but by the way he did it. Instead of going the legislative route -- which even the most unreconstructed ex-commie cannot avoid paying lip service to – Morales issued a decree befitting Stalin. And that, too, on May Day – the day of the year that fires up the international left to resurrect what much of the world has discarded as a losing cause.
To make himself understood, Morales dispatched the armed forces to secure the oil facilities. That’s the kind of radical overhaul Chavez’s revolution envisaged from its inception seven years ago. Venezuela’s state oil firm PDVSA, after all, is advising the Morales government. Chavez visited Morales to support his actions.
Bolivia is not outright expelling foreign companies in the Salvador Allende tradition. Instead, foreign firms will have to sign new contracts within the next 180 days and agree to channel all their sales through the Bolivian state. If they decline, then they would have to leave the country. In most cases, they will have to hand over 82 percent of production to the state.
The Chavez route has won other adherents, which must be worrying to his critics. Ecuador recently approved a law that allows the government to renegotiate contracts with oil companies. Peru’s presidential candidate Ollanta Humala has promised to nationalize gas reserves and production if he wins the runoff election. At the wider trade level, Bolivia, Venezuela and Cuba recently signed the Peoples' Trade Agreement, ostensibly their answer to the Free Trade Area of the Americas. Latin America’s left, however, is not solidly behind Chavez. Brazil, Chile and Uruguay have leftist governments, but they have not pursued nationalization policies.
Can Morales sustain his policy? Bolivia may have South America's second-largest reserves of natural gas, but its oil industry remains underdeveloped. Unlike Venezuela, Bolivia does not have steady oil revenues to fuel further economic growth.
The poorest country in South America, Bolivia is dependent on foreign investment and expertise to extract and export its huge gas reserves.
Morales is the first person who recognizes that energy revenues are nowhere near boosting social and infrastructure spending and securing the country’s long-term debt sustainability.
The best Bolivia can hope for is tighter conditions for foreign firms. So why has Morales exhibited such boldness? Could it have to do with the fact that Chavez calls his cause the Bolivar Revolution?
Tuesday, May 02, 2006
Immigration Debate: Civility Without Change
Behind all the belligerence, the immigration discourse has undergone a semantic change – at least from the pro-immigration side. America now needs illegal aliens from across the southern border to pluck tomatoes not because Americans won’t do the jobs but because employers can’t find Americans to get the job done.
How far this linguistic transformation would inject greater civility into the debate remains to be seen. But it won’t take away the essence.
Go to any gas station, convenience store or motel run by immigrant communities in the Midwest. You see a snapshot of the world – ethnic, demographic and linguistic.
Try striking up a conversation with the youngest-looking guy, especially when the boss (or manager) isn’t around. You discover that those manning the cash registers and front desks are relatives of the owner. How wonderful, these family values so far away from home. Until you realize there are too many Mohammeds and Manohars claiming to be brothers.
Yes, yes, Muslim, Hindu communities tend to use terms of endearment very generously. And don’t they say distance strengthens fondness? Then there are facts of life our affluent society simply can’t understand.
A Hindu grandaunt might have married into a Muslim family. A Muslim uncle might have renounced everything to do with religion except his name for his Hindu beloved. Their descendants might probably still be at each other’s throats if they were still somewhere along the Kashmir line of control. If life in America can breed peace and amity even in one soul, what’s there to complain about?
Moreover, how dare the West lecture on these things when all those white men of yore did so much to tear families asunder on the basis of religion?
Then get out of the premise for a smoke or some fresh air. If you stay long enough you might find a few Americans inquiring around for work? Some will have one job and be on the lookout for some extra buck.
No, the business is not hiring, they’re told inside. The economy still sucks. Just in case, they’re asked to fill out an application for future vacancies. Or at least leave a name, phone number and a good time to call.
The manager won’t call. He’ll probably be too busy yelling at his (illegal) workers, perhaps even threatening to cut their already sub-minimum wage, flaunting that file full of applications.
How far this linguistic transformation would inject greater civility into the debate remains to be seen. But it won’t take away the essence.
Go to any gas station, convenience store or motel run by immigrant communities in the Midwest. You see a snapshot of the world – ethnic, demographic and linguistic.
Try striking up a conversation with the youngest-looking guy, especially when the boss (or manager) isn’t around. You discover that those manning the cash registers and front desks are relatives of the owner. How wonderful, these family values so far away from home. Until you realize there are too many Mohammeds and Manohars claiming to be brothers.
Yes, yes, Muslim, Hindu communities tend to use terms of endearment very generously. And don’t they say distance strengthens fondness? Then there are facts of life our affluent society simply can’t understand.
A Hindu grandaunt might have married into a Muslim family. A Muslim uncle might have renounced everything to do with religion except his name for his Hindu beloved. Their descendants might probably still be at each other’s throats if they were still somewhere along the Kashmir line of control. If life in America can breed peace and amity even in one soul, what’s there to complain about?
Moreover, how dare the West lecture on these things when all those white men of yore did so much to tear families asunder on the basis of religion?
Then get out of the premise for a smoke or some fresh air. If you stay long enough you might find a few Americans inquiring around for work? Some will have one job and be on the lookout for some extra buck.
No, the business is not hiring, they’re told inside. The economy still sucks. Just in case, they’re asked to fill out an application for future vacancies. Or at least leave a name, phone number and a good time to call.
The manager won’t call. He’ll probably be too busy yelling at his (illegal) workers, perhaps even threatening to cut their already sub-minimum wage, flaunting that file full of applications.
Sunday, April 30, 2006
Powell The Politician, Please Rise
Former Secretary of State Colin Powell chose a British television channel to hit back at his archrival, Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld. In an interview with ITV1, Colin said he advised President George W. Bush to send more troops into Iraq before the U.S.-led invasion was launched. The former secretary of state said he gave the advice to now-retired General Tommy Franks, who planned the Iraq invasion, and Rumsfeld. Powell said Bush's military advisors believed the troop level was adequate, a contention he said he still disagrees with.
Considering that Powell was barely on speaking terms with Rumsfeld and Vice-President Dick Cheney, he may have chosen to take a circuitous route to reach his former hard-line associates.
Or maybe the soldier in him asserted itself in more than one way. It emerges that Powell knew he was stretching the truth when he went before the U.N. Security Council with all those pictures proving Saddam Hussein’s weapons of mass destruction posed a clear and present danger to the United States.
We now know, courtesy of Bob Woodward, that President Bush called Powell to inform him of his decision to go to war only after National Security Adviser Condoleezza Rice reminded him it would be the courteous thing to do.
Although Bush seemed to trust the Saudi ambassador more than his own secretary of state, Powell loyally went along every step of the way. Many of us recognize Powell as the “Deep Throat” for Woodward’s “Plan of Attack,” but he was as meticulous as the original man not to leave any fingerprints.
Despite all this restraint, Bush lets a brusque civilian lead America’s proud military on a ruinous path and then stubbornly stands by him. The buck may stop at the commander in chief – with or without a military background. You can’t feel the real anguish of the career people in uniform unless you have been one of them.
Who knows? Maybe a former head of the Joint Chiefs of Staff feels he is under greater obligation than the rest to protect his own. Granted, the transition was shorter than usual after the 2000 elections. Maybe Powell should have insisted on Secretary of Defense more vigorously.
Rumsfeld probably knew where the six retired U.S. generals, who recently called for his resignation faulting his leadership and accusing him of making a series of major errors in the Iraq war, might have picked up the strength to speak.
Maybe he could shrug it off because he knows something else. Powell was the African-American – Republican or Democrat -- with perhaps the best chance as a presidential candidate – until the Iraq war was messed up. The politician in Powell couldn’t have forgiven that, could he?
Considering that Powell was barely on speaking terms with Rumsfeld and Vice-President Dick Cheney, he may have chosen to take a circuitous route to reach his former hard-line associates.
Or maybe the soldier in him asserted itself in more than one way. It emerges that Powell knew he was stretching the truth when he went before the U.N. Security Council with all those pictures proving Saddam Hussein’s weapons of mass destruction posed a clear and present danger to the United States.
We now know, courtesy of Bob Woodward, that President Bush called Powell to inform him of his decision to go to war only after National Security Adviser Condoleezza Rice reminded him it would be the courteous thing to do.
Although Bush seemed to trust the Saudi ambassador more than his own secretary of state, Powell loyally went along every step of the way. Many of us recognize Powell as the “Deep Throat” for Woodward’s “Plan of Attack,” but he was as meticulous as the original man not to leave any fingerprints.
Despite all this restraint, Bush lets a brusque civilian lead America’s proud military on a ruinous path and then stubbornly stands by him. The buck may stop at the commander in chief – with or without a military background. You can’t feel the real anguish of the career people in uniform unless you have been one of them.
Who knows? Maybe a former head of the Joint Chiefs of Staff feels he is under greater obligation than the rest to protect his own. Granted, the transition was shorter than usual after the 2000 elections. Maybe Powell should have insisted on Secretary of Defense more vigorously.
Rumsfeld probably knew where the six retired U.S. generals, who recently called for his resignation faulting his leadership and accusing him of making a series of major errors in the Iraq war, might have picked up the strength to speak.
Maybe he could shrug it off because he knows something else. Powell was the African-American – Republican or Democrat -- with perhaps the best chance as a presidential candidate – until the Iraq war was messed up. The politician in Powell couldn’t have forgiven that, could he?
Thursday, April 27, 2006
India: Policing A Tough Neighborhood
For a determined regional cop, India finds itself working on a chaotic schedule. New Delhi had just managed to push forward a plan to resolve the long-running conflict in its tiny northern neighbor Nepal when trouble broke out on the southern front.
After months of uncertainty, the peace process in Sri Lanka seems to be unraveling. The government and the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) both insist they are committed to peace talks. Intensification in the recent spiral of violence could provide either side – perhaps even both – the excuse to return to fighting, which has already claimed 64,000 lives over a quarter-century.
In Nepal, sustained Indian pressure forced King Gyanendra to restore parliament and hand over power to an opposition alliance that brought hundreds of thousands of people to the streets for almost three weeks.
The patch-up between the palace and parties has not relieved India of much. New Delhi still has to contend with the Nepalese Maoist rebels fighting to overthrow the monarchy. The rebels, whose decade-long “people’s war” with the state has claimed 13,000 lives, control much of Nepal. Indian officials brokered an alliance between mainstream opposition parties and the rebels to force King Gyanendra to shed the absolute powers he seized 15 months ago. Having tamed the palace, Indian officials believe they can encourage the Maoists to lay down arms and join the political process.
New Delhi may have made a promising beginning. The Maoists have announced a three-month ceasefire in the hope that the new government would hold elections to an assembly that the rebels hope would draft a new constitution abolishing the monarchy. Nepalese opposition parties still doubt the Maoists’ new-found commitment to multiparty politics, but seem willing to test it.
For India, a more pressing imperative is at play: the growing menace posed by Indian Maoists. Some 20,000 Naxalites, as the Indian Maoists are known, have arms and are an important factor in states comprising 20 percent of India's population. They pose a serious menace in vast swathes stretching from the Nepal border through the most backward states of north-central India - from Bihar to Jharkand, Chhattisgarh and parts of Orissa, Andhra Pradesh and Maharashtra.
Prime Minister Manmohan Singh recently described the Naxalites as the greatest internal security threat Indian has ever faced. The Maoists’ success in Nepal has directly strengthened and emboldened the Naxalites, something New Delhi has resolved to stop.
Ethnicity, rather than ideology, is what concerns India in Sri Lanka. On April 25, a suicide bomber struck the army’s heavily-fortified headquarters in the capital, Colombo, wounding the country’s hard-line army chief and killing several of his bodyguards.
The bomber was a member of the LTTE, which seeks an independent state for the mainly Hindu Tamils of northern and eastern Sri Lanka.
Originally sympathetic to the LTTE, India has suffered much at the hands of the fierce organization. When New Delhi sent a peacekeeping force to the island nation to protect the Tamils from the Sinhala-dominated government forces at the height of the civil war in the late 1980s, it faced a rude awakening.
The LTTE and Sri Lankan forces joined hands to drive out Indian troops, inflicting heavy losses. (India’s reluctance to intervene militarily in Nepal is partly rooted in the Sri Lankan fiasco.)
Fearing a harsh response from Rajiv Gandhi, the man who dispatched the troops and was set to return to power in 1991, the LTTE did what it long excelled in. It assassinated Gandhi midway through India’s staggered general election.
Although the peace process in Sri Lanka has been steered by the Norwegians, India has been playing critical behind-the-scenes role.
After the Colombo attack, the Sri Lankan government retaliated by mounting air strikes against LTTE positions in the north and east, killing several people and prompting the rebels to warn of more attacks. The fear of renewed war could trigger an exodus of Sri Lankan Tamils to the Indian state of Tamil Nadu. With state elections approaching, Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh certainly cannot be perceived as anti-Tamil – either through his action or inaction.
After months of uncertainty, the peace process in Sri Lanka seems to be unraveling. The government and the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) both insist they are committed to peace talks. Intensification in the recent spiral of violence could provide either side – perhaps even both – the excuse to return to fighting, which has already claimed 64,000 lives over a quarter-century.
In Nepal, sustained Indian pressure forced King Gyanendra to restore parliament and hand over power to an opposition alliance that brought hundreds of thousands of people to the streets for almost three weeks.
The patch-up between the palace and parties has not relieved India of much. New Delhi still has to contend with the Nepalese Maoist rebels fighting to overthrow the monarchy. The rebels, whose decade-long “people’s war” with the state has claimed 13,000 lives, control much of Nepal. Indian officials brokered an alliance between mainstream opposition parties and the rebels to force King Gyanendra to shed the absolute powers he seized 15 months ago. Having tamed the palace, Indian officials believe they can encourage the Maoists to lay down arms and join the political process.
New Delhi may have made a promising beginning. The Maoists have announced a three-month ceasefire in the hope that the new government would hold elections to an assembly that the rebels hope would draft a new constitution abolishing the monarchy. Nepalese opposition parties still doubt the Maoists’ new-found commitment to multiparty politics, but seem willing to test it.
For India, a more pressing imperative is at play: the growing menace posed by Indian Maoists. Some 20,000 Naxalites, as the Indian Maoists are known, have arms and are an important factor in states comprising 20 percent of India's population. They pose a serious menace in vast swathes stretching from the Nepal border through the most backward states of north-central India - from Bihar to Jharkand, Chhattisgarh and parts of Orissa, Andhra Pradesh and Maharashtra.
Prime Minister Manmohan Singh recently described the Naxalites as the greatest internal security threat Indian has ever faced. The Maoists’ success in Nepal has directly strengthened and emboldened the Naxalites, something New Delhi has resolved to stop.
Ethnicity, rather than ideology, is what concerns India in Sri Lanka. On April 25, a suicide bomber struck the army’s heavily-fortified headquarters in the capital, Colombo, wounding the country’s hard-line army chief and killing several of his bodyguards.
The bomber was a member of the LTTE, which seeks an independent state for the mainly Hindu Tamils of northern and eastern Sri Lanka.
Originally sympathetic to the LTTE, India has suffered much at the hands of the fierce organization. When New Delhi sent a peacekeeping force to the island nation to protect the Tamils from the Sinhala-dominated government forces at the height of the civil war in the late 1980s, it faced a rude awakening.
The LTTE and Sri Lankan forces joined hands to drive out Indian troops, inflicting heavy losses. (India’s reluctance to intervene militarily in Nepal is partly rooted in the Sri Lankan fiasco.)
Fearing a harsh response from Rajiv Gandhi, the man who dispatched the troops and was set to return to power in 1991, the LTTE did what it long excelled in. It assassinated Gandhi midway through India’s staggered general election.
Although the peace process in Sri Lanka has been steered by the Norwegians, India has been playing critical behind-the-scenes role.
After the Colombo attack, the Sri Lankan government retaliated by mounting air strikes against LTTE positions in the north and east, killing several people and prompting the rebels to warn of more attacks. The fear of renewed war could trigger an exodus of Sri Lankan Tamils to the Indian state of Tamil Nadu. With state elections approaching, Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh certainly cannot be perceived as anti-Tamil – either through his action or inaction.
Wednesday, April 26, 2006
Grumbling In Global Jihad, Inc.?
With Abu Musab Al-Zarqawi making a 30-minute video appearance on a jihadist website, days after Osama bin Laden’s delivered a fiery audio message, those deciphering the “chatter” must be on overdrive.
A day after the Bin Laden tape was broadcast, three explosions rocked the Sinai Peninsula resort town of Dahab, killing at least 30 people and injuring 160. Most fingers pointed to the Egyptian wing of Al Qaeda.
Throw in Bin Laden deputy Ayman al-Zawahiri’s appeal last month, and you get the feeling that Zarqawi may be up to something infinitely more devastating.
Or maybe not. Consider the dissonance in the three messages. Bin Laden called for jihadists to extend their focus to Sudan and Kashmir, specifying for the first time India as a target. Al Zawahiri, for his part, sought to focus attention on the Palestinian territories. Consider the other incongruity. When Bin Laden, in this week’s tape, used the West's suspension of financial aid to the Palestinian National Authority as evidence of the "Zionist-Crusaders war on Islam," Hamas immediately sought to distance itself from the jihadists. A Hamas spokesman insisted that his group was interested in good relations with the West. Your enemy’s enemy is not always your friend.
Zarqawi is emphasizing the importance of Iraq in the global jihad. Like any sensible commander, he wants all the resources on his front.
But could Zarqawi’s latest appearance be construed as part of another campaign: asserting his claim to a top leadership role in Al Qaeda – perhaps even replacing Bin Laden?
We’ve already heard a lot about the tensions between Zarqawi and the Al Qaeda supreme leadership. As the most prominent battlefield commander – from his perspective, at least -- Zarqawi must think he deserves greater recognition. By issuing videotapes at a time when the other leaders are mostly limited to voice recordings, Zarqawi may feel ahead of the game.
The foot soldiers spread far and wide, moreover, are more likely to be impressed by the exploits of Zarqawi than by the ideological exhortations of leaders on the run. Could we be witnessing a bitter power struggle in Global Jihad Inc? Keep your eyes and ears open for the next series of tapes.
A day after the Bin Laden tape was broadcast, three explosions rocked the Sinai Peninsula resort town of Dahab, killing at least 30 people and injuring 160. Most fingers pointed to the Egyptian wing of Al Qaeda.
Throw in Bin Laden deputy Ayman al-Zawahiri’s appeal last month, and you get the feeling that Zarqawi may be up to something infinitely more devastating.
Or maybe not. Consider the dissonance in the three messages. Bin Laden called for jihadists to extend their focus to Sudan and Kashmir, specifying for the first time India as a target. Al Zawahiri, for his part, sought to focus attention on the Palestinian territories. Consider the other incongruity. When Bin Laden, in this week’s tape, used the West's suspension of financial aid to the Palestinian National Authority as evidence of the "Zionist-Crusaders war on Islam," Hamas immediately sought to distance itself from the jihadists. A Hamas spokesman insisted that his group was interested in good relations with the West. Your enemy’s enemy is not always your friend.
Zarqawi is emphasizing the importance of Iraq in the global jihad. Like any sensible commander, he wants all the resources on his front.
But could Zarqawi’s latest appearance be construed as part of another campaign: asserting his claim to a top leadership role in Al Qaeda – perhaps even replacing Bin Laden?
We’ve already heard a lot about the tensions between Zarqawi and the Al Qaeda supreme leadership. As the most prominent battlefield commander – from his perspective, at least -- Zarqawi must think he deserves greater recognition. By issuing videotapes at a time when the other leaders are mostly limited to voice recordings, Zarqawi may feel ahead of the game.
The foot soldiers spread far and wide, moreover, are more likely to be impressed by the exploits of Zarqawi than by the ideological exhortations of leaders on the run. Could we be witnessing a bitter power struggle in Global Jihad Inc? Keep your eyes and ears open for the next series of tapes.
Sunday, April 23, 2006
Europe’s Immigration Dilemma
As leading member-states of the European Union continue to press for tighter immigration controls, a number of developments have taken place.
Riots between locals and North African immigrants over law-and-order disputes are becoming appallingly common.
Far right parties, stoking fears of foreigners, have gained ground.
Proposals have been made for a hefty bond for certain categories of visa applicants in a claimed bid to deter potential asylum-seekers.
The European Union, on the other hand, has come out with reports saying that only an increase in the number of immigrants could compensate for the steady drop in labor supply in the 25-member bloc.
The United Nations Population Fund, too, says that by 2025, the EU would be home to 35 million fewer people than today - a serious problem in view of projections that 159 million new workers will be needed to maintain current labor structures.
A decline in the labor market would tend to affect much more than jobs and income.
With life expectancy increasing in EU nations, governments will be under pressure to earmark additional funds to cover the cost of pensions and health and social benefits for their senior citizens.
The case for more workers paying into social security systems cannot, therefore, be overstated.
At the political level, Britain, Germany and France hope to lay down common policies for accepting immigrants.
Specifically, they want to devise measures to ensure that an immigrant or asylum-seeker rejected in one EU member-state is rejected by all.
Their enthusiasm in seeking increased cooperation against organized crime rings dealing in illegal immigrants is understandable considering the burden such migrants tend to place on the labor market and social security systems.
The growth in right-wing parties in some EU nations may be partly attributed to the social and economic dislocations triggered by the influx of illegal aliens.
Political expediency would force mainstream parties to act tough on immigration while economic prudence would encourage them to adopt an opposite course of action.
EU governments could move to tackle this apparent dichotomy by educating the people on the clear distinctions between legal and illegal immigration and the different realities they represent.
Riots between locals and North African immigrants over law-and-order disputes are becoming appallingly common.
Far right parties, stoking fears of foreigners, have gained ground.
Proposals have been made for a hefty bond for certain categories of visa applicants in a claimed bid to deter potential asylum-seekers.
The European Union, on the other hand, has come out with reports saying that only an increase in the number of immigrants could compensate for the steady drop in labor supply in the 25-member bloc.
The United Nations Population Fund, too, says that by 2025, the EU would be home to 35 million fewer people than today - a serious problem in view of projections that 159 million new workers will be needed to maintain current labor structures.
A decline in the labor market would tend to affect much more than jobs and income.
With life expectancy increasing in EU nations, governments will be under pressure to earmark additional funds to cover the cost of pensions and health and social benefits for their senior citizens.
The case for more workers paying into social security systems cannot, therefore, be overstated.
At the political level, Britain, Germany and France hope to lay down common policies for accepting immigrants.
Specifically, they want to devise measures to ensure that an immigrant or asylum-seeker rejected in one EU member-state is rejected by all.
Their enthusiasm in seeking increased cooperation against organized crime rings dealing in illegal immigrants is understandable considering the burden such migrants tend to place on the labor market and social security systems.
The growth in right-wing parties in some EU nations may be partly attributed to the social and economic dislocations triggered by the influx of illegal aliens.
Political expediency would force mainstream parties to act tough on immigration while economic prudence would encourage them to adopt an opposite course of action.
EU governments could move to tackle this apparent dichotomy by educating the people on the clear distinctions between legal and illegal immigration and the different realities they represent.
Friday, April 21, 2006
Berlusconi: Sore Loser Or Shrewd Realist?
Italian Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi is as stubborn in defeat as he was in success. The country’s highest court has confirmed the narrow victory of Romano Prodi's center-left coalition in this month’s general election. For the incumbent, that’s not enough to concede defeat.
Is Berlusconi becoming politically delusional? After all, he reversed the electoral law that had produced relative political stability, returning to a proportional representation system. Instead, that shift produced a fragmented verdict.
During the campaign, Berlusconi continued to exploit his media empire to get disproportionate television coverage for himself and his party. Has failure in the face of such advantages aggravated his malady?
Actually, Berlusconi seems to have his politics right. By questioning an outcome he knows he will inevitably have to accept, Berlusconi may be fortifying his arsenal. Prodi's coalition is fractious enough in terms of personality and ideology. Making it vulnerable to incessant opposition attacks could be one way of reclaiming the mandate Berlusconi feels should have been his all along.
Ordinarily, such callous regard for the people’s will might have sounded the death knell on a politician. With fraudulent elections – at least the perception of them – no longer the exclusive preserve of Third World autocracies, Berlusconi evidently feels he has time on his side.
In another country, such a dogged refusal to yield to the bedrock principle of democracy might have fueled concerns about its political stability. Here, too, Berlusconi feels sufficiently strong. Post-war Italy has averaged about a government a year.
Prodi’s inheritance is hardly enviable, particularly so on the economic front. Berlusconi’s government proved a grave disappointment on the vital reforms needed to improve Italy's competitiveness. The result: Italy is at the lowest rung of the eurozone ladder.
Moreover, Prodi is hamstrung by the strong showing of far-left constituents of his alliance, especially the unreconstructed Communists led by Fausto Bertinotti.
A prominent opponent of large-scale reforms, Bertinotti hopes to undo the labor-market reform introduced by Berlusconi to encourage the use of temporary and short-term contracts. The way French leaders burned their fingers in a similar cauldron will have only bolstered Bertinotti’s hand.
Prodi, more than anyone else, remembers how it was Bertinotti’s withdrawal of support that brought down his previous centre-left government in 1998. No wonder the premier-elect can’t seem to sit back and let Berlusconi’s theatrics run their course.
Is Berlusconi becoming politically delusional? After all, he reversed the electoral law that had produced relative political stability, returning to a proportional representation system. Instead, that shift produced a fragmented verdict.
During the campaign, Berlusconi continued to exploit his media empire to get disproportionate television coverage for himself and his party. Has failure in the face of such advantages aggravated his malady?
Actually, Berlusconi seems to have his politics right. By questioning an outcome he knows he will inevitably have to accept, Berlusconi may be fortifying his arsenal. Prodi's coalition is fractious enough in terms of personality and ideology. Making it vulnerable to incessant opposition attacks could be one way of reclaiming the mandate Berlusconi feels should have been his all along.
Ordinarily, such callous regard for the people’s will might have sounded the death knell on a politician. With fraudulent elections – at least the perception of them – no longer the exclusive preserve of Third World autocracies, Berlusconi evidently feels he has time on his side.
In another country, such a dogged refusal to yield to the bedrock principle of democracy might have fueled concerns about its political stability. Here, too, Berlusconi feels sufficiently strong. Post-war Italy has averaged about a government a year.
Prodi’s inheritance is hardly enviable, particularly so on the economic front. Berlusconi’s government proved a grave disappointment on the vital reforms needed to improve Italy's competitiveness. The result: Italy is at the lowest rung of the eurozone ladder.
Moreover, Prodi is hamstrung by the strong showing of far-left constituents of his alliance, especially the unreconstructed Communists led by Fausto Bertinotti.
A prominent opponent of large-scale reforms, Bertinotti hopes to undo the labor-market reform introduced by Berlusconi to encourage the use of temporary and short-term contracts. The way French leaders burned their fingers in a similar cauldron will have only bolstered Bertinotti’s hand.
Prodi, more than anyone else, remembers how it was Bertinotti’s withdrawal of support that brought down his previous centre-left government in 1998. No wonder the premier-elect can’t seem to sit back and let Berlusconi’s theatrics run their course.
Tuesday, April 18, 2006
Putin On A Show
Having fortified his flank at home, Russian President Vladimir Putin is on the way to restoring his nation’s Soviet-era international glory. The upcoming summit of G-8 industrialized democracies is precisely the kind of event the Kremlin sees as its passport to global stardom.
Not very long after he took office, U.S. President George W. Bush began singing paeans to Putin’s sincerity. That look in his eyes was simply unmistakable. When the United States withdrew from the Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty, Moscow barely took notice. Full-fledged G-8 membership was but a small token of appreciation from his allies.
This extended endorsement coincided with the period Putin began moving against his political opponents, big business, the independent media and started centralizing the power his predecessor, Boris Yeltsin, had devolved – deliberately and by default – to the regions.
The U.N. Security Council deliberations preceding the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq, Moscow’s meddling in Ukraine’s political process, and the Kremlin’s curbs on international non-government organizations deepened doubts about Putin’s worthiness as an international statesman.
The democratic path chosen by Ukraine, Moldova and Georgia and Baltic countries prompts sneers in the Kremlin, which has developed special friendship with Belarus, Iran, Uzbekistan and Venezuela. The sole criterion Moscow meets for continued membership of the G-8 is the size of its economy.
By refusing to attend the St. Petersburg summit, it is argued, G-8 leaders could send a powerful signal to Putin to mend his ways. Such a drastic step, on the other hand, could alienate Russia and encourage it toward other misadventures. So which way will Russia’s G-8 partners decide?
They will probably go ahead with the summit in St. Petersburg. Putin, after all, enjoys considerable popularity among ordinary Russians. If anyone comes up with overwhelming evidence of rigged opinion polls, well, we can see to that then.
Not very long after he took office, U.S. President George W. Bush began singing paeans to Putin’s sincerity. That look in his eyes was simply unmistakable. When the United States withdrew from the Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty, Moscow barely took notice. Full-fledged G-8 membership was but a small token of appreciation from his allies.
This extended endorsement coincided with the period Putin began moving against his political opponents, big business, the independent media and started centralizing the power his predecessor, Boris Yeltsin, had devolved – deliberately and by default – to the regions.
The U.N. Security Council deliberations preceding the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq, Moscow’s meddling in Ukraine’s political process, and the Kremlin’s curbs on international non-government organizations deepened doubts about Putin’s worthiness as an international statesman.
The democratic path chosen by Ukraine, Moldova and Georgia and Baltic countries prompts sneers in the Kremlin, which has developed special friendship with Belarus, Iran, Uzbekistan and Venezuela. The sole criterion Moscow meets for continued membership of the G-8 is the size of its economy.
By refusing to attend the St. Petersburg summit, it is argued, G-8 leaders could send a powerful signal to Putin to mend his ways. Such a drastic step, on the other hand, could alienate Russia and encourage it toward other misadventures. So which way will Russia’s G-8 partners decide?
They will probably go ahead with the summit in St. Petersburg. Putin, after all, enjoys considerable popularity among ordinary Russians. If anyone comes up with overwhelming evidence of rigged opinion polls, well, we can see to that then.
Friday, April 14, 2006
The Dems To Rummy’s Rescue?
The script is getting a little bland. Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld’s critics call for his head; President George W. Bush reaffirms his full faith in the whole man.
Rumsfeld looks secure; his enemies wait for another day… which arrives sooner than they expect.
Except this time, it’s Rummy’s generals who are after him – retired generals, I mean. The dainty half a dozen – Maj Gen Charles H Swannack Jr, Maj Gen John Riggs, Maj Gen John Batiste, Gen Anthony Zinni, Lt Gen Gregory Newbold and Maj Gen Paul Eaton -- present a lively portrait. For instance, not all say it was wrong for the United States to invade Iraq.
Their possible motives, too, are newsworthy. Gen. Zinni is in the middle of a tour promoting a new book critical of the Bush administration. Gen. Riggs left the Pentagon in 2004 after clashing with civilian leaders and then being investigated for potential misuse of contractor personnel.
Where the six are most united is in asserting that Rumsfeld and his aides too often inserted themselves unnecessarily into military decision-making, often disregarding advice from military commanders.
Like the rest of us, our men (and women) just out of uniform are entitled to the perspective of hindsight. Moreover, their loyalty to the institution they served with such distinction as to have risen to the top ranks – if that is what has even faintly impelled them to speak -- should be admired.
All the same, politics could hardly have been at the back of their minds. Amid the rising concern about the death toll in Iraq, there has been a precipitous fall in Bush’s popularity ratings.
Bush would be the last person to ditch Rumsfeld. It would be an admission of error. The president took the rather unusual step of defending Rumsfeld while he was away at Camp David.
"I have seen first-hand how Don relies upon our military commanders in the field and at the Pentagon to make decisions about how best to complete these missions," Bush said in a statement.
"Secretary Rumsfeld's energetic and steady leadership is exactly what is needed at this critical period. He has my full support and deepest appreciation."
In an interview with Al Arabiya television, Rumsfeld himself rejected the generals' criticism. "Out of thousands and thousands of admirals and generals, if every time two or three people disagreed we changed the secretary of defense of the United States it would be like a merry-go-round."
Rumsfeld, to be sure, has been a lightning rod for Bush critics. He was blamed for committing too few U.S. troops and for underestimating the strength of the insurgency. He took heat in 2004 over the abuse of Iraqi prisoners at the U.S. Army-run Abu Ghraib prison. And who can forget that brusque response he gave to an Army National Guard soldier in Kuwait who questioned him on inadequate armor.
Iraq might just have provided the excuse. Some of the tensions between Rumsfeld and the uniformed military services date back to his arrival at the Pentagon in early 2001. Rumsfeld's assertion of greater civilian control over the military and his calls for a slimmer, faster force were viewed with mistrust by many senior officers.
The Rumsfeld doctrine was dark enough on its merits. Its author’s aggressive and often abrasive style could only have earned him the eternal enmity of many.
We’re told there are several other former military leaders ready to attest to the worst in Rumsfeld. Would he hand in another resignation letter and persuaded the president to accept it? Who would be in the running to succeed him, considering how hot the Pentagon seat has become under him?
Rush Limbaugh had this brilliant idea. Dick Cheney should be sent back to his old office in the Pentagon to ponder the multilateralism of Bush 41. Condy Rice should be brought in as veep. Forget about who becomes Secretary of State and watch how Condy Rice’s gaze goes straight to New Hampshire and Iowa.
Maybe the Democrats might mount the best case for Rumsfeld to stay.
Rumsfeld looks secure; his enemies wait for another day… which arrives sooner than they expect.
Except this time, it’s Rummy’s generals who are after him – retired generals, I mean. The dainty half a dozen – Maj Gen Charles H Swannack Jr, Maj Gen John Riggs, Maj Gen John Batiste, Gen Anthony Zinni, Lt Gen Gregory Newbold and Maj Gen Paul Eaton -- present a lively portrait. For instance, not all say it was wrong for the United States to invade Iraq.
Their possible motives, too, are newsworthy. Gen. Zinni is in the middle of a tour promoting a new book critical of the Bush administration. Gen. Riggs left the Pentagon in 2004 after clashing with civilian leaders and then being investigated for potential misuse of contractor personnel.
Where the six are most united is in asserting that Rumsfeld and his aides too often inserted themselves unnecessarily into military decision-making, often disregarding advice from military commanders.
Like the rest of us, our men (and women) just out of uniform are entitled to the perspective of hindsight. Moreover, their loyalty to the institution they served with such distinction as to have risen to the top ranks – if that is what has even faintly impelled them to speak -- should be admired.
All the same, politics could hardly have been at the back of their minds. Amid the rising concern about the death toll in Iraq, there has been a precipitous fall in Bush’s popularity ratings.
Bush would be the last person to ditch Rumsfeld. It would be an admission of error. The president took the rather unusual step of defending Rumsfeld while he was away at Camp David.
"I have seen first-hand how Don relies upon our military commanders in the field and at the Pentagon to make decisions about how best to complete these missions," Bush said in a statement.
"Secretary Rumsfeld's energetic and steady leadership is exactly what is needed at this critical period. He has my full support and deepest appreciation."
In an interview with Al Arabiya television, Rumsfeld himself rejected the generals' criticism. "Out of thousands and thousands of admirals and generals, if every time two or three people disagreed we changed the secretary of defense of the United States it would be like a merry-go-round."
Rumsfeld, to be sure, has been a lightning rod for Bush critics. He was blamed for committing too few U.S. troops and for underestimating the strength of the insurgency. He took heat in 2004 over the abuse of Iraqi prisoners at the U.S. Army-run Abu Ghraib prison. And who can forget that brusque response he gave to an Army National Guard soldier in Kuwait who questioned him on inadequate armor.
Iraq might just have provided the excuse. Some of the tensions between Rumsfeld and the uniformed military services date back to his arrival at the Pentagon in early 2001. Rumsfeld's assertion of greater civilian control over the military and his calls for a slimmer, faster force were viewed with mistrust by many senior officers.
The Rumsfeld doctrine was dark enough on its merits. Its author’s aggressive and often abrasive style could only have earned him the eternal enmity of many.
We’re told there are several other former military leaders ready to attest to the worst in Rumsfeld. Would he hand in another resignation letter and persuaded the president to accept it? Who would be in the running to succeed him, considering how hot the Pentagon seat has become under him?
Rush Limbaugh had this brilliant idea. Dick Cheney should be sent back to his old office in the Pentagon to ponder the multilateralism of Bush 41. Condy Rice should be brought in as veep. Forget about who becomes Secretary of State and watch how Condy Rice’s gaze goes straight to New Hampshire and Iowa.
Maybe the Democrats might mount the best case for Rumsfeld to stay.
Tuesday, April 11, 2006
Mubarak And The Clash of Civilizations
Egypt’s President Hosni Mubarak has triggered a firestorm in his neighborhood by saying something commonly heard in the Sunni Arab street. In an interview with Al Arabiyah TV, Mubarak said most of the Shia in the Middle East were loyal to Iran, and not to the countries they resided in.
Predictably enough, the most vigorous response came from Iraq. President Jalal Talabani, Prime Minister Ibrahim Jaafari and Parliament Speaker Adnan Pachachi – the three top Kurdish, Shia and Sunni leaders of the country -- issued a joint statement criticizing Mubarak for "taking a stab at Shia Iraqis’ patriotism and civilization.” Outrage poured in from quarters as diverse as the Hezbollah and Shia members of Kuwait’s parliament.
Infused by this rather unexpected bestowal of authority, Iran conceded wielding immense influence among Iraqi Shias, adding it was spiritual in nature. Coming from a theocracy, the last qualification was perhaps redundant.
In reality, President Mubarak only repeated a variation of concerns King Abdullah of Jordan and Saudi Foreign Minister Prince Saud Al-Faisal had voiced last year: The rise of Shias in Iraq could come at the expense of all Arab Sunnis.
Most of the Sunni regimes in region hated Saddam Hussein; they were among the first to commiserate his departure. If the containment of the Baathist regime ever continued to made sense, it was among the leaders of these Sunni regimes.
Three years after Saddam’s fall, there is no single Arab state that is even close to becoming as strong as Iran. Arab Sunni leaders also recognize that their own legacy of bickering would prevent the emergence of one anytime soon. Most Sunni Arab states, on the other hand, have sizeable Shia minorities. They could get all kinds of wrong ideas from their newly resurgent Iraqi cousins, especially with Washington and Teheran courting them.
At a philosophical level, the prospect of an American-Iranian deal on Iraq is baffling to many Arab Sunnis. Many Americans still can’t figure out how 15 of 19 9/11 hijackers turned out to be nationals of a traditional American ally like Saudi Arabia. Most Sunni Arabs will have an equally hard time understanding how Americans could be so eager to talk to Iran’s Ayatollahs on stabilizing Iraq while threatening to nuke their own suspected nuclear-weapons facilities.
Then the commander of Iran’s Revolutionary Guards steps in to complicate matters. Last week, he called on United States to accept Teheran as the regional hegemon. Now even the most paranoid Sunni knows such a quid pro quo is far-fetched. But, then, wasn’t that the precise role successive U.S. administrations had conferred on the Shah’s regime.
Mubarak may have had another motive. Contrary to conventional wisdom in the West, Iran is not an Arab state. It resents the misconception. The one thing the ayatollahs had no problem inheriting from the Shah was the notion of the supremacy of Iran’s Persian heritage.
Could Mubarak, the leader of another cradle of civilization, have wanted to expose the clash of civilizations within the Islamic world? Not really far-fetched, eh?
Predictably enough, the most vigorous response came from Iraq. President Jalal Talabani, Prime Minister Ibrahim Jaafari and Parliament Speaker Adnan Pachachi – the three top Kurdish, Shia and Sunni leaders of the country -- issued a joint statement criticizing Mubarak for "taking a stab at Shia Iraqis’ patriotism and civilization.” Outrage poured in from quarters as diverse as the Hezbollah and Shia members of Kuwait’s parliament.
Infused by this rather unexpected bestowal of authority, Iran conceded wielding immense influence among Iraqi Shias, adding it was spiritual in nature. Coming from a theocracy, the last qualification was perhaps redundant.
In reality, President Mubarak only repeated a variation of concerns King Abdullah of Jordan and Saudi Foreign Minister Prince Saud Al-Faisal had voiced last year: The rise of Shias in Iraq could come at the expense of all Arab Sunnis.
Most of the Sunni regimes in region hated Saddam Hussein; they were among the first to commiserate his departure. If the containment of the Baathist regime ever continued to made sense, it was among the leaders of these Sunni regimes.
Three years after Saddam’s fall, there is no single Arab state that is even close to becoming as strong as Iran. Arab Sunni leaders also recognize that their own legacy of bickering would prevent the emergence of one anytime soon. Most Sunni Arab states, on the other hand, have sizeable Shia minorities. They could get all kinds of wrong ideas from their newly resurgent Iraqi cousins, especially with Washington and Teheran courting them.
At a philosophical level, the prospect of an American-Iranian deal on Iraq is baffling to many Arab Sunnis. Many Americans still can’t figure out how 15 of 19 9/11 hijackers turned out to be nationals of a traditional American ally like Saudi Arabia. Most Sunni Arabs will have an equally hard time understanding how Americans could be so eager to talk to Iran’s Ayatollahs on stabilizing Iraq while threatening to nuke their own suspected nuclear-weapons facilities.
Then the commander of Iran’s Revolutionary Guards steps in to complicate matters. Last week, he called on United States to accept Teheran as the regional hegemon. Now even the most paranoid Sunni knows such a quid pro quo is far-fetched. But, then, wasn’t that the precise role successive U.S. administrations had conferred on the Shah’s regime.
Mubarak may have had another motive. Contrary to conventional wisdom in the West, Iran is not an Arab state. It resents the misconception. The one thing the ayatollahs had no problem inheriting from the Shah was the notion of the supremacy of Iran’s Persian heritage.
Could Mubarak, the leader of another cradle of civilization, have wanted to expose the clash of civilizations within the Islamic world? Not really far-fetched, eh?
Saturday, April 08, 2006
Let’s Define Democracy, First
Even in the midst of what has become a virtual civil war, the bickering factions in Iraq’s newly elected parliament are no closer to producing a government. The interim prime minister, Ibrahim Jaafri, a Shia, is denouncing American concerns at the delay as unwarranted interference. What a charade of coalition building.
For many in the Bush administration, the spectacle in Baghdad is democracy in action. To be sure, the escalation in Shia-Sunni fighting has diverted attention from continuing casualties on American forces.
Vietnam, Lebanon and Somalia are too seared in the bipartisan consciousness in Washington for Americans to declare victory and withdraw. Even the worst critics of Bush’s decision to invade and occupy Iraq ardently favor staying the course in order to deter terrorism by building democracy.
What democracy? F. Gregory Gause explains in an update to his intrepid essay "Can Democracy Stop Terrorism?" (Foreign Affairs, September/October 2005) nearly two-thirds of the candidates elected to the new Iraqi parliament last December won on platforms that explicitly called for a greater role for Islam in politics.
Among the 215 Arab parliamentarians elected (the others being Kurds and smaller minority group representatives), 81 percent campaigned on lists that were sectarian and Islamist. Granted, not all of these people believe in obliterating America to save the world. Some do come quite close, though. Here’s the shocker: only nine percent came from the explicitly secular, non-sectarian, and multiethnic Iraqi National List of former Prime Minister Iyad Allawi.
Take the other two manifestations of democracy in action elsewhere in the volatile region – Egypt and the Palestinian Authority. The Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood won 88 seats, 20 percent of the 444 elected seats, in the November-December balloting tightly controlled by President Hosni Mubarak’s regime.
Gause explains that this figure understates the significance of the Brotherhood's showing. The group had fielded only about 150 candidates as part of a tacit agreement with the government that allowed Brotherhood candidates to campaign openly, and so it won almost 60 percent of the seats it contested. Liberal, leftist, and nationalist opposition parties, on the other hand, won 11 seats, fewer than 3 percent of the total.
In January’s elections to the Palestinian parliament, Hamas -- the political wing of the Palestinian Muslim Brotherhood – trounced Fatah, the late and hesitant convert to peace founded by Yasir Arafat. Hamas carried 56 percent of the seats against Fatah's 34 percent. Liberal, leftist, and other nationalist parties won seven percent.
Proponents of democracy must reconcile themselves with the emergence of Islamists in certifiably open elections. If this demonstration of the popular will is the kind of success the Bush administration envisions for the wider region – and eventually the rest of the world – then it needs to sort things out. Freeze on aid to a Hamas government is not the kind of encouragement Palestinian voters expect.
The creation of a liberal-secular-nationalist base across the Arab world probably is the best America can hope for. Such formations may require several electoral cycles in most places. Still struggling to form a government three months after the elections, Iraq is the model the region should avoid.
For many in the Bush administration, the spectacle in Baghdad is democracy in action. To be sure, the escalation in Shia-Sunni fighting has diverted attention from continuing casualties on American forces.
Vietnam, Lebanon and Somalia are too seared in the bipartisan consciousness in Washington for Americans to declare victory and withdraw. Even the worst critics of Bush’s decision to invade and occupy Iraq ardently favor staying the course in order to deter terrorism by building democracy.
What democracy? F. Gregory Gause explains in an update to his intrepid essay "Can Democracy Stop Terrorism?" (Foreign Affairs, September/October 2005) nearly two-thirds of the candidates elected to the new Iraqi parliament last December won on platforms that explicitly called for a greater role for Islam in politics.
Among the 215 Arab parliamentarians elected (the others being Kurds and smaller minority group representatives), 81 percent campaigned on lists that were sectarian and Islamist. Granted, not all of these people believe in obliterating America to save the world. Some do come quite close, though. Here’s the shocker: only nine percent came from the explicitly secular, non-sectarian, and multiethnic Iraqi National List of former Prime Minister Iyad Allawi.
Take the other two manifestations of democracy in action elsewhere in the volatile region – Egypt and the Palestinian Authority. The Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood won 88 seats, 20 percent of the 444 elected seats, in the November-December balloting tightly controlled by President Hosni Mubarak’s regime.
Gause explains that this figure understates the significance of the Brotherhood's showing. The group had fielded only about 150 candidates as part of a tacit agreement with the government that allowed Brotherhood candidates to campaign openly, and so it won almost 60 percent of the seats it contested. Liberal, leftist, and nationalist opposition parties, on the other hand, won 11 seats, fewer than 3 percent of the total.
In January’s elections to the Palestinian parliament, Hamas -- the political wing of the Palestinian Muslim Brotherhood – trounced Fatah, the late and hesitant convert to peace founded by Yasir Arafat. Hamas carried 56 percent of the seats against Fatah's 34 percent. Liberal, leftist, and other nationalist parties won seven percent.
Proponents of democracy must reconcile themselves with the emergence of Islamists in certifiably open elections. If this demonstration of the popular will is the kind of success the Bush administration envisions for the wider region – and eventually the rest of the world – then it needs to sort things out. Freeze on aid to a Hamas government is not the kind of encouragement Palestinian voters expect.
The creation of a liberal-secular-nationalist base across the Arab world probably is the best America can hope for. Such formations may require several electoral cycles in most places. Still struggling to form a government three months after the elections, Iraq is the model the region should avoid.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)